.png)
October Gift Guides for Pen Makers: Why This Month Can Make or Break Your Holiday Sales
- renaealk
- Sep 25
- 6 min read
Pens are more than tools—they’re tiny magic wands. ✨ With a flick of the wrist, they turn ideas into ink, moments into memory. And in October, that magic doesn’t just sit on your workbench—it can ignite your entire sales season.
But here’s the spooky truth: some pen makers are buried in Halloween orders before the candy runs out, while others don’t see real action until mid-December (if at all). Why? It isn’t about luck or follower count. It’s about strategy—specifically, how you use seasonal gift guides.
Think of gift guides as treasure maps. 🗺️ Done right, they don’t just showcase your pens; they lead customers directly to their perfect Halloween or Holiday gift—with you at the “X.” This blog is your compass. I’ll show you how to craft blog post guides that attract and inspire, and landing page guides that convert and sell. Put them together, and you’ve got the one-two punch that turns October into your busiest, most profitable month of the year.
Why Gift Guide Timing Is Everything For Pen Makers
Halloween is a flash mob. It shows up with energy, orange-and-black flair, and a dash of mystery—then vanishes overnight. If you wait until October 25 to launch your spooky pen guide, you’re showing up to the party just as the lights are turning on.
That’s why you need to launch Halloween guides by October 10. Early enough to catch attention, but close enough to the date to feel urgent. Highlight pens that scream seasonal fun: a pumpkin-swirl fountain pen, gothic engravings, glow-in-the-dark accents, or bundles of orange and black ink. These items sell like impulse candy at checkout—fast, themed, and irresistible.
Christmas, on the other hand, is a long, slow symphony. 🎶 Buyers start scouting in October, especially corporate customers and thoughtful gifters. They mull over engraved heirloom pens, luxury writing sets, and stocking stuffer minis. They plan purchases around deadlines: personalization by Dec 10, shipping by Dec 15. Unlike Halloween, these sales snowball, building from October through the season’s crescendo.
The bottom line? Treat Halloween like a sprint—fun, fast, done in days. Treat Christmas like a marathon—planned, built on anticipation, and designed to peak at the right time. With timing clear, let’s talk about how to package your guides.
Blog Post Gift Guides = Attract & Inspire
Your blog gift guide is your seasonal storybook. It’s not a dry product list—it’s where you charm your readers into picturing themselves gifting (or receiving) your pens. Think glossy magazine meets SEO strategy.
Here’s how it works:
Storytelling: Instead of “Black Resin Pen—$75,” write, “Our Midnight Raven Pen glistens like a haunted forest under moonlight—perfect for jotting ghost stories this October.” For Christmas: “The Snowfall Rollerball is etched with frosted detail, a gift that writes every holiday card for years to come.”
SEO Keywords: Weave in phrases buyers actually search: Halloween pen gift, spooky stationery, Christmas stocking stuffer pens, personalized pen gifts. This ensures your blog shows up in Google results.
Emotional Pull: People trust makers who inspire them. A blog guide lets you show your expertise and passion while highlighting products in a way that feels curated, not salesy.
Think of your Halloween blog as a lantern in a haunted house—it draws curious buyers in with glow and intrigue. Your Holiday blog is more like a fireside story—it lingers, warms, and stays in memory. Both are designed to attract—but attraction alone won’t pay the bills.
Landing Page Gift Guides = Convert & Sell
If blogs inspire, landing pages seal the deal. They’re your seasonal storefront window, perfectly staged for the buyers who are ready to click “Add to Cart.”
Here’s how pen makers should set them up:
Halloween Landing Page Ideas:
Spooky Pens Collection: black/orange resins, gothic clips, glow-in-the-dark details.
Pumpkin Ink Bundles: pen + orange/black ink bottles.
Under $50 Treats: budget-friendly themed minis.
Holiday Landing Page Ideas:
Luxury Heirloom Pens: exotic woods, gold trim, engraving options.
Stocking Stuffers: pocket pens, festive ink samples.
Holiday Writing Sets: pen + journal + ink in a gift box.
Structure is key:
Clean product grids with crisp photos.
2–3 sentence blurbs highlighting use cases.
Bold Buy Now buttons that don’t get lost.
Shipping deadlines front and center: “Order personalized pens by Dec 10 | Standard shipping closes Dec 15.”
Why it works: landing pages remove friction, simplify choices, and add urgency. Without them, readers who fell in love with your Pumpkin Swirl Pen in your blog post may wander off without buying.
How They Work Together as a One-Two Punch
Think of your blog as the party invitation and your landing page as the dance floor. 🕺 One gets people excited, the other gets them moving.
Here’s how the journey flows:
A shopper Googles “Halloween pen gift.”
They land on your blog: “7 Spooky Pens for Writers This October.”
They read your story about the Pumpkin Swirl Pen glowing under candlelight.
A link takes them to your Halloween landing page.
They see a banner: “Only 8 left—ships in time for Halloween.”
They buy. 🎉
The beauty? Blogs keep pulling organic traffic long after Halloween. Landing pages, meanwhile, are perfect for ads and email blasts. They’re partners, not rivals—one inspires, the other converts. Ignore either piece, and your October map is missing its “X.”
Useful ChatGPT Prompts for Creating Guides
Blank pages are scary, but AI can help you banish that ghost. 👻 With the right prompts, ChatGPT can hand you a draft that’s 80% done—leaving you to add your product photos, stories, and sparkle.
Here are two ready-to-use prompts:
Prompt 1 – Blog Post Gift Guide Copy
"I am a handmade pen maker. Write a sparkly, fun-to-read blog post (800–1,200 words) for my [Halloween/Holiday] Gift Guide. Include an engaging hook, storytelling about why pens make meaningful gifts, product highlights, and a call-to-action. Suggest 3 SEO blog titles and a meta description."
Prompt 2 – Landing Page Gift Guide Copy"
I am a handmade pen maker. Write high-converting landing page copy for my [Halloween/Holiday] Gift Guide. Include a headline, subhead, product grid blurbs (3–4 sentences each), urgency messaging with shipping deadlines, and a strong CTA. Keep it concise, persuasive, and gift-focused."
One maker used Prompt 1 to draft their Holiday blog. With just a few tweaks—adding photos of their snowflake engravings and a personal story about gifting a pen to their dad—they had a polished post that ranked on Google and resonated with readers.
Common Mistakes
Many pen makers sabotage their own success without realizing it. Here are the big missteps to avoid:
Publishing too late. A Halloween guide on October 28? Useless. A Christmas guide in late November? You’ve missed the planners.
Dry catalog style. If your guide reads like a spreadsheet, readers won’t care. They want stories, not SKU numbers.
No blog-to-landing link. Blogs without a “Shop the Guide” button are like haunted houses with no doors.
Ignoring deadlines. Nothing crushes trust faster than a customer who buys too late and misses Christmas morning.
Avoid these traps, and your guides become assets, not afterthoughts.).
Conversion Tricks & Cross-Sells
Want to boost order value without more traffic? Add some conversion sparkle:
Sticky cart buttons: Keep “Add to Cart” visible as they scroll.
Urgency banners: “Engraving closes in 48 hours.”
Bundles: Package pens with seasonal extras.
Topic-specific cross-sells:
Halloween: spooky ink bottles, pumpkin-themed journals, glow pen cases.
Christmas: red/green ink refills, leather-bound journals, engraved wooden boxes.
Example: One maker added ink refill suggestions to their Holiday landing page. Result? 30% of carts included the add-on, raising average order value without extra marketing. 🎁
Final Thoughts
You don’t need to be haunted by marketing fears to win October. With the right gift guides, you can light up the season. Think of Halloween as your sparkler—quick, dazzling, unforgettable. Think of Christmas as your bonfire—steady, glowing, and irresistible. Together, they’ll illuminate your busiest quarter of the year.
Start today: use the prompts, draft your guides, and give your pens the spotlight they deserve. Because the only thing scarier than Halloween isn’t skeletons—it’s missing out on sales your pens should have earned. 🎃🔥🎄
👋 Want more prompts like these, plus marketing tips for handmade sellers?
Join my free email list for weekly inspiration, writing tools, and creative ideas to help you grow your shop.
💬 Need help crafting your content, finding your story, or building a brand voice that sells?
Book a free intro call—I work with makers who want to sell more by saying more.
And hey, let’s be pen friends:
Or just email renaealk@gmail.com if you’ve got a question.
You don’t have to guess your way through marketing. Here’s free sales strategies we made just for handmade pen sellers —and if you're stuck, reach out for a free call to talk about what’s holding your shop back.
What pen's do you think would work for this gift guide? Share a product link
(It'll help with SEO)
<3