Why Are Your Email Open Rates So Low? Here’s How to Fix It.

You’ve spent hours writing the perfect email — warm subject line, great story, gorgeous pen photos. You hit send. And then… crickets. 🦗 Not because your customers don’t care, but because your email never even made it to their inbox. Ugh.

Low email open rates are the silent business killer. But the good news? It’s fixable. And you don’t need to be a tech wizard to do it. Let’s break down what’s going wrong (in plain English) and how to fix it today — so your next email actually lands.

Problem 1: Your List Is Dirty

If your emails are bouncing left and right, inbox providers will assume you’re careless—or worse, a spammer. And here’s the kicker: they don’t just punish the bad addresses. They lower your overall sender reputation, which means even the good subscribers stop seeing your emails. It’s like inviting 100 people to a party, but 20 invitations get returned because the addresses don’t exist. Pretty soon, the post office wonders if you even know your guests.

🚩 Red Flags

• High hard bounce rate → When emails don’t exist, every failed attempt chips away at your credibility. Too many, and providers start flagging you as risky.

• Typos in email addresses → Common culprits like gmial.com or yahhoo.com sneak in easily. Each typo is another “ghost” that hurts deliverability.

• Questionable sources → Uploading old event lists, scribbled craft fair sign-ups, or — yikes — purchased lists often adds errors and spam traps.

🛠 Fix It

• Run verification checks: Tools like NeverBounce or Kickbox clean your list before you hit send.

• Remove inactive subscribers: Scrub every 3–6 months. Smaller, healthier lists perform better.

• Stop uploading random lists: If you can’t vouch for it, don’t send to it.

✅ Remember: a clean list = higher trust, better inbox placement, and more people actually reading your emails.

Problem 2: You’re Emailing the Dead

Sending to subscribers who haven’t opened your emails in months is like talking to an empty room. Inactive users weigh down your list, drag your sender score into the gutter, and signal to inbox providers that maybe your content isn’t valuable. That hurts your reputation with the very people who actually want to hear from you.

🚩 Red Flags

• Opens have flatlined → If subscribers haven’t engaged in 60–90 days, they’re basically ghosts on your list.

• High inactive ratio → When a large percentage of your list ignores you, inbox providers assume your emails don’t belong in the primary inbox.

• No segmentation → Treating engaged buyers and silent subscribers the same is a one-way ticket to the spam folder.

🛠 Fix It

• Segment and test: Pull out contacts who haven’t opened in 60–90 days and treat them differently.

• Run a re-engagement campaign: Use subject lines like “Still want to hear from us?” or offer an incentive.

• Sunset the ghosts: If they don’t bite, remove them. Yes, it stings, but a smaller, active list delivers better results than a big, dead one.

✅ Think of it as pruning a plant — cut the dead leaves so the healthy parts can thrive.

Problem 3: You Might Be Hitting Spam Traps

Spam traps are fake email addresses planted by inbox providers to catch sloppy senders. They look real, but if you send to one, it’s a giant red flag that you’re not cleaning your list. Hit enough traps and your entire domain reputation can tank overnight.

🚩 Red Flags

• You’ve bought a list → Spam traps are designed to sit on those.

• You haven’t cleaned in ages → Old, abandoned addresses often turn into traps.

• You mass-blast everyone → If you never segment by engagement, you increase the odds of hitting a trap.

🛠 Fix It

• Never buy lists. Ever. If the addresses didn’t come from people who opted in, they don’t belong.

• Clean frequently: Use services like NeverBounce or Kickbox to keep your list fresh.

• Segment by engagement: Focus on active subscribers. Reward the people who open, click, and reply — not the ghosts.

✅ Spam traps are like hidden landmines. Careless senders step on them. Careful senders never get near them.

Problem 4: Your Sender Reputation Is in Trouble

Inbox providers like Gmail and Outlook don’t just judge your emails — they judge you. They assign a hidden “score” to your sending domain and IP. If you’ve been marked as spam too often, your reputation tanks. And once your rep is bad, even your best emails end up in the junk folder.

🚩 Red Flags

• Spam complaints piling up → If too many subscribers click “This is spam,” providers take it seriously.

• No domain authentication → Without SPF, DKIM, or DMARC, you look shady to inbox filters.

• Unexplained volume spikes → Sending 10x more emails overnight screams “spammer” to Gmail.

🛠 Fix It

• Set up authentication: Make sure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are configured with your domain. Your email tool usually walks you through it.

• Check your reputation: Use Google Postmaster Tools to see how Gmail views your sending domain.

• Warm up gradually: If you’re scaling, increase volume slowly. Build trust one batch at a time.

✅ Protect your reputation like it’s your credit score. Once it’s trashed, it takes time and consistent effort to rebuild.

Problem 5: Your Content Looks… Spammy

Even if your list is squeaky clean and your domain is trusted, your email content itself can trip alarms. Spam filters look at your subject lines, formatting, and links — and if it feels shady, it gets flagged.

🚩 Red Flags

• Clickbait subject lines → “BUY NOW!!!” or “You Won’t Believe This” scream scam.

• Image-only emails → Filters prefer scannable text. A giant graphic with no words? Risky.

• Messy links → Broken or misleading links get you penalized.

🛠 Fix It

• Write subject lines like a human: Be clear, conversational, and specific. Curiosity is great, trickery is not.

• Balance text and images: Aim for at least 60% text, 40% images.

• Test before you send: Use Mail-Tester.com to see how your email scores with spam filters.

✅ Remember: if your email looks like spam, inbox providers will treat it like spam. Keep it clean, keep it clear, keep it real.

Problem 6: You Didn’t Warm Up Properly

Starting to send from a brand-new domain or IP? Inboxes don’t trust you yet. If you blast your whole list at once, providers panic — and your delivery tanks. Think of it like walking into a party and shouting at everyone at once. Awkward.

🚩 Red Flags

• New domain, no history → Zero track record makes you suspicious.

• Volume spikes → Going from 0 to 5,000 sends overnight sets off alarms.

• No warm-up plan → Treating new senders like old ones is a rookie mistake.

🛠 Fix It

• Start small: Send to your most engaged subscribers first (the ones who always open).

• Ramp up slowly: Increase your send volume over 2–4 weeks, not overnight.

• Focus on quality: Prioritize content that sparks opens, clicks, and replies. Positive engagement builds trust faster than any tool.

✅ Warming up is like training for a marathon. Slow, steady consistency beats sprinting out of the gate and crashing.

Audit Email Open Rates Before You Panic

A low delivery rate doesn’t mean your email marketing is doomed. It’s just a signal—a blinking dashboard light telling you something needs attention.

Here’s your basic triage:

Possible Issue	Quick Fix
Dirty list	Verify and clean emails
Cold subscribers	Segment or sunset
Spam traps	Use clean, permission-based lists
Domain issues	Check SPF/DKIM/DMARC
Spammy content	Balance images + text, avoid clickbait
New domain/IP	Warm up slowly with engaged users

Want to Dig Deeper?

If you’re still stuck, don’t guess. Tools like Postmark, Google Postmaster Tools, or MXToolbox can give you data to make informed decisions.

Because the best email in the world means nothing if it never makes it to the inbox.

Because here’s the truth: email is still one of the most powerful marketing tools you have. It’s like texting someone after a first date — if you do it right, they want to see you again. If you ghost them or overwhelm them, they disappear.

And if your emails have been landing in spam? That’s not failure. That’s feedback. You can fix this. You’re not invisible. Your work matters. Your pens deserve inbox space.

Low email open rate isn’t the end of the world — it’s just a nudge to clean up your process. Tweak your subject lines. Scrub your list. Set up your tech basics. And keep sending. Because the only way to really fail in email marketing is to stop trying.

So go ahead — send the email. Even if you’re scared. Even if your last one tanked. Do it scared. Hit send. Your people are waiting. 💌

Your pen has a story—make sure your customers hear it. Try today’s lessons on your next email, and then come tell me how it went. I love seeing how makers like you bring your materials to life.

👋 Want more prompts like this, plus marketing tips for handmade sellers?

Join my free email list for weekly inspiration, writing tools, and creative ideas to help you grow your shop.

💬 Need help crafting your content, finding your story, or building a brand voice that sells?Book a free intro call—I work with makers who want to sell more by saying more.

And hey, let’s be pen friends:

Follow on Instagram

Follow on Facebook

Or just email renaealk@gmail.com if you’ve got a question.