The Smart Maker’s Guide to Business Plans, Money, and Mistakes to Avoid

You’ve turned your first pens, sold a few, and now you’re staring at the big question: How do I turn this hobby into a real business?

Here’s the truth: beautiful pens and raw talent will get you noticed. But if you want to build something that lasts — something that pays for itself, grows over time, and doesn’t crash the minute life throws you a curveball — you need a plan.

Today, we’re tackling the “unsexy” side of your pen business: business plans, legal and financial basics, and common pitfalls to avoid. Trust me, this isn’t about boring paperwork. It’s about giving yourself a foundation sturdy enough to hold the dream you’re building.

📋 What Should I Include in My Business Plan?

A business plan sounds intimidating, right? Like it belongs in a corporate office with beige walls and a 40-page binder. But for makers like us, it doesn’t have to be that way. Think of your plan as a roadmap — something that keeps you from wandering in circles when the creative brain wants to spin the lathe all day instead of thinking about marketing.

Here’s what a simple, powerful business plan for your pen shop should include:

1. Your Business Goals

What do you want from this business? Extra weekend income? A side hustle that pays for family vacations? A full-time career? Write it down. Clear goals shape every decision that follows.

👉 Example: “Within 12 months, I want to cover all business expenses with pen sales and pay myself $500/month.”

2. Target Market Analysis

Not all pen buyers are created equal. Who’s most likely to buy your pens? Collectors? Journalers? Gift buyers? Executive professionals? The clearer your picture, the easier it is to design products, pricing, and marketing that actually land.

✨ Tip: Picture your “dream buyer.” Where do they shop? What do they care about? What problem are they solving when they buy your pen?

3. Marketing Strategies

How will people actually find you?

• Social media (Instagram, Facebook, YouTube)

• Marketplaces (Etsy, Shopify, your own site)

• In-person events (craft fairs, boutiques)

• Email marketing (build that list early!)

Your marketing section doesn’t have to be fancy — it just has to answer: “How will I get eyes on my pens?”

4. Financial Projections

Don’t glaze over here — this is the heartbeat of your plan. Estimate what you’ll spend (materials, kits, blanks, tools, marketing) and what you expect to earn (pen sales, custom orders). Even rough numbers give you a reality check.

👉 Example: If your average pen sells for $85, and you want $500/month profit, you’ll need to sell around 10 pens monthly after costs.

5. Operational Plan

Who does what, when, and how? In a solo shop, that’s mostly you — but writing it down helps. Decide how often you’ll turn new stock, when you’ll update your Etsy listings, how you’ll handle shipping, etc.

6. Unique Selling Proposition (USP)

What makes your pens stand out? Maybe it’s your use of rare woods, your sports/history themes, or your colorful resins. Spell it out. This becomes the anchor for your brand story.

👉 Think of your USP as the one-liner you’d tell someone at a craft show when they pick up your pen: “These pens are made from reclaimed barn wood — you’re literally holding a piece of history.”

✨ Remember: Your business plan doesn’t have to be a novel. A one-page plan written in plain language is 100x better than no plan at all.

What Legal and Financial Considerations Should I Be Aware Of?

Okay, deep breath. This is the section most makers want to skip — but skipping it can cost you big later. The good news? A few smart steps now will save you headaches (and money) down the line.

1. Business Licenses + Registrations

Every area is different, so check your local regulations. At minimum, you may need a simple business license to sell at fairs or online. If you’re serious, consider registering an LLC to separate your personal and business finances (and protect your assets).

2. Taxes

Yes, even side hustles have to report income. Keep good records of your sales and expenses — materials, tools, shipping, booth fees. Those receipts can lower your taxable income.

👉 Pro tip: Open a separate bank account for your pen business. It keeps everything clean and makes tax season less stressful.

3. Intellectual Property Protection

If you’ve got a killer brand name or logo, consider trademarking it to prevent copycats. For most beginners, this can wait — but keep it in mind as you grow.

4. Financial Management

Budgeting isn’t glamorous, but it’s powerful. Track what you spend. Track what you earn. And set aside a portion for reinvestment (new tools, better blanks) and for paying yourself.

✨ Think of your financial system as another lathe tool. It shapes your business just as much as your gouges shape the wood.

What Are Some Common Pitfalls to Avoid in the Pen Business?

Let’s be real: every maker stumbles. The key is learning from mistakes before they sink you. Here are the traps I see new pen businesses fall into most often:

1. Underestimating Marketing

You can turn the most beautiful pen in the world, but if nobody sees it, it won’t sell. Don’t treat marketing as an afterthought. Treat it as part of the craft — the part that connects your work to its new home.

2. Mispricing Products

Too low, and you burn out working for pennies. Too high, and buyers don’t understand why. Do the math, research the market, and price with confidence.

3. Neglecting Customer Service

A single unanswered email or slow shipping experience can cost you repeat buyers. Communicate clearly. Be proactive. A little kindness goes a long way.

4. Poor Inventory Management

Stockouts = lost sales. Overstocking = money tied up in materials. Track your blanks, kits, and finished pens so you’re always ready to sell.

5. Failing to Adapt

Markets shift. Instagram changes. A supplier goes out of business. Don’t cling to “the way it’s always worked.” Stay curious, keep testing, and adapt when needed.

✨ Remember: Mistakes aren’t failures — they’re feedback.

Final Thoughts

Building a pen business is about more than sanding and polishing. It’s about giving yourself the structure to grow without chaos. A simple business plan, smart financial habits, and awareness of common pitfalls create a safety net that lets you dream bigger.

The best part? None of this has to be perfect. You don’t need a 40-page binder or a finance degree. You just need clarity, consistency, and courage to keep going.

So — write that one-page plan. Open that separate bank account. Sketch out your USP. Avoid the traps. Your pens deserve a business as strong and beautiful as the grain you turn.

👉 Want to go deeper? This post is just the map. Click into my other guides for step-by-step help with Turn Buyers Into Fans; Crafting the Perfect Online Shop; Plans, Legal, and Money Basics; Pricing, Branding, and Standing Out; How to Market and Sell

Your pens are already special. Now it’s time to make sure the world sees them.

✍️ Your pen has a story — make sure the world hears it. Every photo, every caption, every email is a chance for someone to connect with your craft.

👋 Want more practical tips (without the overwhelm)?

Join my free email list for weekly inspiration, writing tools, and creative ideas to help you grow your shop.

Need personalized help building your brand voice or content strategy?

Book a free intro call—I work with makers who want to sell more by saying more.

And hey, let’s be pen friends:

Follow on Instagram

Follow on Facebook

Or just email renaealk@gmail.com if you’ve got a question.